Kate Foster Professional Editing Services
  • General Blog
  • #EditFoster Blog!
  • Talking Middle Grade
  • THE REJECTION CARE PACKAGE

250 Word Critique # 1, 2017

29/1/2017

3 Comments

 
We're back! Kicking off 2017 with the very popular 250 word critiques! Yes, this was supposed to go live last week but we've been flat out editing your incredible books!

​Right, today we have a fairly controversial first 250 of a YA sci-fi. Controversial in that it has split the #EditFoster camp.

One editor wants changes, one isn't so sure. So, we want your feedback. How would you edit this opening page? Would you recommend revisions? Would you read on?

​Here we go...


It’s difficult to tell what I feel the loudest. I’ve reached the end, and it’s as if I’ve captured a breath after staying underwater too long. Yet more consuming than relief is the uncertainty of what waits for me on the surface.

But whether I’m ready for it or not, after today, everything I’ve worked for will be mine: the title of captain, the finest ship in the galaxy, but mostly the freedom of open space.  

My uncle’s voice seeps into my head. “Is there freedom in the promise of war, Tethys? Will you attain it with your heart or demand it with the point of a sword?”

I clench my eyes against the thought. No, I won’t go there. If ever I needed confidence in the Acquisition, it’s today. Focus on the final trial, on your last test, and prove you’re the woman Uncle believes you to be. I step forward, yanking at the sleeves of my armored bodysuit. My boots glide soundlessly over the training hall’s sleek, metal floor.

From ground up, the domed, reflective glass panels ripple like a snake’s glossy skin to reveal the Guta moon and the sun peeking just over its shoulder. I inhale the familiar stringent scent of a recently sterilized room. And in the hazy glow of early morning, the cavernous room atop the Acquisition Starship wraps me in the chill and quietness of deep space.
​
Yet nothing can still the wild thrumming of my heart.

​Our first editor says:

"​Fantastic, strong writing. Very stylish. We meet the character and see that she’s determined, ambitious, successful, that she appears to crave freedom; we start to ask questions like ‘reached the end of what?’ and ‘what war?’ and ‘why does she think of her uncle and not her parents?’; we see some confusion in her mind through her uncle’s voice, a possible clue into her internal conflict. Completely enthralling with a strong voice that will push a reader to keep reading. No edits recommended at this stage!

​And our second editor says:

"While the writing is strong, I feel some attention needs to be given to setting to orient the reader as to where things are happening, as well as showing more action instead of beginning with the character’s musings. The first page provides the opportunity to connect the reader with the protagonist. Show me an immediate scene with action and description, plus, if it works, dialogue. Show me how whatever happens has consequences for the protagonist.  The reader doesn’t need set-up because the story should be happening NOW. What is the inciting event, or what’s different that day that will change the direction for the protagonist?  And lastly, what happens on the first page should raise a story question—what happens next? Or why did that happen? Overall, the writing is superb."

​So, please, leave your comments below! Thanks for stopping by.
3 Comments
Lou Grimm link
29/1/2017 06:59:03 pm

I love it as is! Except for the 'step forward' and 'soundlessly', two of the most overused terms in writing...

I totally agree with Editor 1 at this stage, but I'm anticipating the action within the next 100 words or so - maybe a roaring crowd? A thrusted weapon? A yelling commander?

I don't care *where* things are happening yet - I know enough to make me jump in, so no, don't bog me down with descriptions. And I'm already asking 'what happens next?'

Reply
B Jones
30/1/2017 03:34:52 am

I agree with the second editor in that I need some action and description to help give me a sense of orientation. I do feel the MC's passionate characterization though.

Reply
resume writer link
25/8/2017 03:28:31 am

This professional editing services website have always been serving the writers and editors by providing them with the best jobs and earn their living in a handsome manner. it is also a great platform for the readers as well.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Blog Schedule

    Every Wednesday and Saturday we bring you an edit tip of the day. Be sure to check out the archives for our popular summer series of SHOW DON'T TELL workshops! 

    Archives

    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016

    Categories

    All
    Characterization Tips
    Common Mistakes
    Critiques
    Dialogue Tips
    Editing Tips
    Query Tips
    Show Vs Tell
    Structure
    Writer's Block

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • General Blog
  • #EditFoster Blog!
  • Talking Middle Grade
  • THE REJECTION CARE PACKAGE